Discussion archive

Top Disability related benefits topic #2385

Subject: "lighthearted cynicism" First topic | Last topic
Tony Bowman
                              

Welfare Rights Advisor, Reading Community Welfare Rights Unit
Member since
25th Nov 2004

lighthearted cynicism
Mon 24-Oct-05 01:38 PM

Hi folks,

How about some humour to lighten up this dreary Monday afternoon?

Looking at the news item regarding ATOS origin, I see that they are proposing 'purpose-built' examination centres for people claiming AA/DLA.

Initially, I found it quite baffling - what can be in a room for examining DLA/AA claimants that's not in the usual examination room? And then I hit upon it! In addition to the usual stuff: couch, sphygmomenometer, stethoscope, etc.; we might find the following:

A WADDELL'S SIGNS DETECTOR,

A TREADMILL WITH A MINIMUM DISTANCE OF 50 METRES BEFORE STOPPING

SOUNDPROOFING!


Any more.....................??????

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: lighthearted cynicism, bensup, 24th Oct 2005, #1
RE: lighthearted cynicism, Margie, 24th Oct 2005, #2
      RE: lighthearted cynicism, S. McCarthy, 25th Oct 2005, #3
           RE: lighthearted cynicism, Semitone, 25th Oct 2005, #4
                RE: lighthearted cynicism, SimonMee, 25th Oct 2005, #5
RE: lighthearted cynicism, past caring, 25th Oct 2005, #6
RE: lighthearted cynicism, Semitone, 25th Oct 2005, #7
      RE: lighthearted cynicism, past caring, 25th Oct 2005, #8
           RE: lighthearted cynicism, northwiltshire, 04th Nov 2005, #9
                RE: lighthearted cynicism, SLloyd, 04th Nov 2005, #10
RE: lighthearted cynicism, CAS, 08th Nov 2005, #11
RE: lighthearted cynicism, garym65, 08th Nov 2005, #12
      RE: lighthearted cynicism, Margie, 08th Nov 2005, #13
           RE: lighthearted cynicism, Semitone, 09th Nov 2005, #14
                RE: lighthearted cynicism, Margie, 09th Nov 2005, #15

bensup
                              

Benefits Supervisor, Barrow-in-Furness, Cumbria Citizens Advice Bureau
Member since
24th May 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Mon 24-Oct-05 02:16 PM

Hillarious!!

  

Top      

Margie
                              

Senior Welfare Rights Officer, prescot & whiston community advice centre
Member since
13th Apr 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Mon 24-Oct-05 02:30 PM

a conventional cooker complete with ingredients to prepare and cook a simple meal for one?

  

Top      

S. McCarthy
                              

Welfare Rights Worker CCMHT, Chesterfield Community Mental Health
Member since
18th Oct 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 25-Oct-05 09:22 AM

Just make sure you don't ask to use the toilet half way through the examination.

  

Top      

Semitone
                              

welfare rights officer, Redcar & Cleveland Welfare Rights
Member since
22nd Jan 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 25-Oct-05 10:25 AM

shopping trolley, commode, hidden camera, fraud officer ready to pounce in IUC mode, sodium pentothal, Jeremy Beadle

  

Top      

SimonMee
                              

Welfare Rights Officer - Community Care Team, Nottinghamshire Welfare Rights Service
Member since
05th Feb 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 25-Oct-05 12:29 PM

....at least 100m from the nearest road/car park, recorded by CCTV of course

  

Top      

past caring
                              

welfare rights worker, Blackfriars Advice Centre, London
Member since
27th Jul 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 25-Oct-05 02:06 PM

Your forgetting the most important thing of all - a couple of random, untrained punters, grabbed off the street to decide the claim.

  

Top      

Semitone
                              

welfare rights officer, Redcar & Cleveland Welfare Rights
Member since
22nd Jan 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 25-Oct-05 02:29 PM

Our clients use Middlesbrough medical centre at present and thats one of those to be closed. We used Travel Direct to assess what travel arrangements would apply to a client living in a village further down the coast who will have to travel to the new "Purpose built examination centre" in Thornaby. One hour 31 minutes.

Big guffaw. It starts off by instructing "Walk to Carlin How- 12 minutes". It happens to be about 1-11/2 miles but its all uphill-about 1 in 4. I could'nt do it in 12 minutes never mind someone with a heart condition or musculoskeletal problem. It would probably kill them off.

So add to the list- oxygen, paramedics, adrenaline and de-fribrillators for those poor sods breaking a gut to get there.

  

Top      

past caring
                              

welfare rights worker, Blackfriars Advice Centre, London
Member since
27th Jul 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 25-Oct-05 02:36 PM

"It would probably kill them off."

Kill or cure, eh? Could well be the intention.

  

Top      

northwiltshire
                              

welfare rights officer, c.a.b. n.wiltshire
Member since
26th Jan 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Fri 04-Nov-05 11:50 AM

Well a one off funeral payment is cheaper than weekly on going payments. Oh such cynism. Though it does remind me of a conversation with Frank Field in 1997 just after the election win (oh what a false dawn that was, things could only get better HA!)we were in a rural area so people had too swap between several buses to get to his surgeries after benefits had been stopped so they couldn't be that disabled. When we explained the option was £20 taxi fares and they then go home and suffer for days with the after effect, we then politely pointed out we win most of these appeals , he then had the cheek to tell us we were obviuosly doing too good a job.Ho those politicians hey ho.

  

Top      

SLloyd
                              

Welfare Rights Adviser/Trainee Solicitor, Thorpes Solicitors, Hereford
Member since
03rd Feb 2005

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Fri 04-Nov-05 11:55 AM

What about a special computer that feeds on carefully drafted EMP reports and and spews out unreadable scribble...

  

Top      

CAS
                              

Welfare Benefits Officer, Falkirk Council
Member since
22nd Oct 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 08-Nov-05 02:18 PM

a football pitch
a bath
a slotted spoon

  

Top      

garym65
                              

Welfare benefits Caseworker/Supervisor, Walthamstow CAB
Member since
21st Jul 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 08-Nov-05 02:45 PM

back to work people, when all this comes true you won't be laughing!!!

  

Top      

Margie
                              

Senior Welfare Rights Officer, prescot & whiston community advice centre
Member since
13th Apr 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Tue 08-Nov-05 05:37 PM

You might have a point...could this thread be hijacked as a new Department Think Tank????

  

Top      

Semitone
                              

welfare rights officer, Redcar & Cleveland Welfare Rights
Member since
22nd Jan 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Wed 09-Nov-05 07:22 AM

If thats possible add to the list free Budweiser,60 inch plasma screen with free access to all sky sports channels and unlimited credit at Ladbrookes.

  

Top      

Margie
                              

Senior Welfare Rights Officer, prescot & whiston community advice centre
Member since
13th Apr 2004

RE: lighthearted cynicism
Wed 09-Nov-05 07:46 AM

and a lobotomy?

  

Top      

Top Disability related benefits topic #2385First topic | Last topic