Discussion archive

Top Housing Benefit & Council Tax Benefit topic #4694

Subject: "housing benefit when mother owns the property" First topic | Last topic
dcarlin
                              

Paralegal, Housing Team, Hopkin Murray Beskine Solicitors, London
Member since
06th Dec 2005

housing benefit when mother owns the property
Mon 19-Mar-07 04:00 PM

Can my client claim housing benefit for accommodation which her mother owns. Mother lives elsewhere. Client claims that this is a commercial arrangement, mother needs to let out the property and has let it to client.
I am aware that she would not be eligible for HB if she and mother were cohabiting.

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: housing benefit when mother owns the property, penny newell, 19th Mar 2007, #1
RE: housing benefit when mother owns the property, ariadne2, 20th Mar 2007, #2

penny newell
                              

Freelance welfare rights consultant and trainer, Training Benefits, London
Member since
02nd Feb 2004

RE: housing benefit when mother owns the property
Mon 19-Mar-07 04:30 PM

short answer - yes could claim but would need to show it is a commercial arrangement and not a contrived tenancy. But that only takes your client over the first hurdle. The next hurdle would be how much rent and then the son's income. How old is the son?
(oh there is never a short answer to a benefit question)
More information needed i think.

  

Top      

ariadne2
                              

Welfare lawyer and social policy collator, Basingstoke CAB
Member since
13th Mar 2007

RE: housing benefit when mother owns the property
Tue 20-Mar-07 09:43 PM

Is the client already renting the property or is there a liability to pay rent? If the tenancy agreement only comes into existence when HB appears on the horizon ("you can pay me rent if you get HB but otherwise you just live there anyway") this would raise the spectre of both a tenancy contrived to take advantage of the HB scheme and a non-commercial agreement. There are problems with consideration if the laibility to pay rent is not absolute. LAs will often ask in these circumstances if the mother would evict the daughter if she doesn't pay rent (I say often, because it's not by any means an uncommon thing, and many such tenancies do succeed). They will also wonder what the purpose of the tenancy is - I can't help feeling that an arrangement to allow Mum to pay for rent elsewhere/a mortgage etc has more of the ring of a commercial agreement than one whose main purpose is not to let daughter be homeless.

Is there a tenancy agreement? Is there a rent book? Whose repsonsibility are things like maintenance and insurance?

Lots of questions indeed. But it certainly isn't impossible.

  

Top      

Top Housing Benefit & Council Tax Benefit topic #4694First topic | Last topic