Discussion archive

Top Housing Benefit & Council Tax Benefit topic #3944

Subject: "CH/3393/2003" First topic | Last topic
Neil Bateman
                              

Welfare rights consultant, www.neilbateman.co.uk
Member since
24th Jan 2004

CH/3393/2003
Thu 05-Oct-06 04:39 PM

Does anyone have a copy of CH/3393/2003? Concerns treatment of income from borrowing on credit cards.

All offers gratefully accepted...

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: CH/3393/2003, ken, 06th Oct 2006, #1
RE: CH/3393/2003, Neil Bateman, 06th Oct 2006, #2

ken
                              

rightsnet, lasa
Member since
28th Jul 2005

RE: CH/3393/2003
Fri 06-Oct-06 02:45 PM

CH/3393/2003 is now available on rightsnet.

  

Top      

Neil Bateman
                              

Welfare rights consultant, www.neilbateman.co.uk
Member since
24th Jan 2004

RE: CH/3393/2003
Fri 06-Oct-06 03:52 PM

Thanks - I think that whatever the correct legal approach, this is a decision which is undesirable in social policy terms: withdrawing cash on credit cards may be counted as income provided that the minimum monthly repayments are maintained.

However, in case anyone reading this thinks this is definitive: it may well not be settled law because the Commissioner in R(H) 5/05 (para 48) hinted at a desire to consider whether CH/3393/2003 was correctly decided.

I suspect that one would need to have an undertanding of consumer credit and banking law to make progress and it may also depend on the terms of each credit card agreement.

  

Top      

Top Housing Benefit & Council Tax Benefit topic #3944First topic | Last topic