Discussion archive

Top Housing Benefit & Council Tax Benefit topic #6733

Subject: "Non-dependant deduction" First topic | Last topic
jutucker
                              

Welfare Benefits Adviser, Shelter Cymru
Member since
30th Apr 2008

Non-dependant deduction
Mon 16-Jun-08 01:35 PM

I have a client who is having a £7.40 non-dep charge applied to his claim. Both he and I have asked the LA to look at this decision again in light of the fact that the non-dep only stays at the client's house a few nights per week. It is not his permanent home as he does not keep his belongings there. Basically he "sofa surfs" between 3 different addresses. He stays at my client's address, who is his father, for support as he is a recovering drug addict. The LA has used this as one of the reasons not to remove the charge.

I have quoted CD CIS/14850/96 in my argument to get the charge removed but the LA are refusing, saying that his absence from the property is temporary and he is resident for sufficient time for the house to be regarded as the individual's usual abode.

In addition, as his post is sent there and he is registered with JCP at this address this must be his permanent residential address. The JCP records also indicate that during Dec 07 the non-dep advised that he was "living with his dad".

Has anyone got any ideas where I can now go with this or have I hit a brick wall??

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: Non-dependant deduction, jmembery, 16th Jun 2008, #1
RE: Non-dependant deduction, jutucker, 16th Jun 2008, #2
RE: Non-dependant deduction, stainsby, 20th Jun 2008, #3

jmembery
                              

Benefits Manager AVDC, Aylesbury Vale DC - Aylusbury bucks
Member since
01st Mar 2004

RE: Non-dependant deduction
Mon 16-Jun-08 02:24 PM

Have a look at some more recent decisions such as CH 1781 2005 and CH 3935 2007 if you have not already as they may give you some pointers.

Jeff

  

Top      

jutucker
                              

Welfare Benefits Adviser, Shelter Cymru
Member since
30th Apr 2008

RE: Non-dependant deduction
Mon 16-Jun-08 02:34 PM

I will do, thanks!

  

Top      

stainsby
                              

Welfare Benefits Officer, Gallions Housing Association, Thamesmead SE London
Member since
22nd Jan 2004

RE: Non-dependant deduction
Fri 20-Jun-08 04:24 PM

The LA might well refuse but could loose at Tribunal. In CIS/14850/1996, the so called non dep had no other address.

A person should be considered to be not normally resideing anywhere if he sofa surfs.

See also CH/3935/2007 another case where a non deps stay was at least initially temporary.

  

Top      

Top Housing Benefit & Council Tax Benefit topic #6733First topic | Last topic